American restaurants

Main Eatery

4.4 279 reviews Closed 511 W Main St, McArthur, OH 45651, United States

Discover this place

Main Eatery, nestled at 511 W Main St in McArthur, Ohio, is a delightful American restaurant that has quickly captured the hearts of locals and travelers alike. Known for its vast menu, it stands out for its inviting atmosphere and family-friendly vibe. Customers rave about the exceptional quality of the food, with highlights including the best Reuben sandwich and pig nachos, described as absolutely delicious by satisfied patrons. The milkshake selection is a true spectacle, offering unique flavors like cranberry orange and classic favorites that make it a treat worth stopping for. One customer noted the experience of indulging in a cranberries shake paired with a Footlong Coney—a combination that embodies the spirit of comfort food. With a cozy interior that sparkles at night, Main Eatery provides an ideal setting for unwinding after a day of hiking at nearby Hocking Hills or simply enjoying a meal with loved ones. Whether you opt for their Bacon Cheddar Potato Soup or the sweet Banana Split, you’ll find that every dish is crafted with care and creativity. A must-visit for food lovers, Main Eatery is a testament to the charm and richness of American dining.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service
Great dessert
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Main Eatery before visiting.

Reviews for Main Eatery

4.4

279 reviews

100%

30%

17%

Review highlights

Based on 279 reviews

Main Eatery, an American restaurant located in McArthur, OH, is widely praised for its diverse and innovative menu that appeals to a broad audience. Customers frequently highlight the extensive selection of unique flavors and creative dishes, ranging from classic sandwiches to inventive shakes and desserts. The eatery's family-friendly atmosphere and ample seating create a comfortable environment for both casual visits and leisurely stops after outdoor activities. Reviewers also appreciate the accommodating and patient staff who assist with menu choices. Overall, Main Eatery is recognized as a must-visit destination offering consistently satisfying food and a welcoming ambiance, making it a popular choice for locals and travelers alike.

A J

Jun 03, 2025

An amazing food stop near lake hope. Wide selection of food and drinks for the whole family. Must visit if you are in the area, there is plenty of seating for you to relax. We went in the afternoon but it seems they have decorated it with lights so night time will be even better experience.

Alisha Yeauger

May 07, 2025

The BEST food! We have went by plenty of times and never stopped and I'm so so glad we did this time. BEST Reuben I have ever had and the pig nachos were absolutely delicious

Katie Vaughan

Apr 02, 2025

BEST FOOD IN THE WHOLE TOWN!!! Great place to stop if youre passing through or after a busy day of hiking at hocking hills!!

Michael Fargo

Mar 30, 2025

Great menu selection! They had flavors I've never heard of before. I tried a cranberry orange shake... Honestly I think it was the best shake I've ever had!! Banana Splits, Sundaes, Cones, Shakes, Frozen Bars, they have it all! I'll definitely be going back there soon! Update; 2 months later I returned and got that cranberry shake again along with a Footlong Coney with onions! Good thing I don't live across the street from this place,

Leigh M

Mar 21, 2025

Fantastic little eatery. Very patient with non-locals overwhelmed by their huge menu. Grasshopper, turtle, and mudslide brain freezes, orange-raspberry shake, and cuban sandwich were all fantastic!!!

IsJERRYZ Kid

Mar 13, 2025

Milkshakes so thick , you almost need a spoon!!! The banana splits are delectable too. They have a dining room & the billboard offers the specials of the day, I.E. sandwich with drink @ ??? Seems to be busy as well . Stop by and say hi!

james fletcher

Mar 07, 2025

This was one of the BEST little places I have ever been! Garbage Fries caught my eye as we passed it. We stopped back and got Shrimp and Clams dinner and Philly Steak BOTH off the chain ! The MUSHROOMS... Now listen to me... Anywhere else, you might get 6-7 mushrooms for 5-6, little Nuke Bombs, guaranteed to take the skin off the roof of your mouth. HERE... for the 12 Large, and I DO MEAN LARGE, it seems they quarter the whole mushroom, hand batter them, and throw the crispies in ( like LJS fish) THESE are an ABSOLUTE MUST ! ABSOLUTELY STOP HERE !!! You will NOT be disappointed !

Chuck Kinney

Mar 07, 2025

Dining room was closed, so we ate outside at the picnic tables. Food was great and the portions are huge! You actually get what you pay for here! Fried Tenderloin sammich is HIGHLY recommended! Grandson had a chicken wrap and it must have been 2 pounds! Very friendly staff and your order it up quick! Will definitely stop on our next trip